Book Review by Ashley Lucas: Inside This Place, Not of It, Eds. Robin Levi and Ayelet Waldman

5 Sep

Inside This Place, Not of It: Narratives from Women’s Prison provides a chilling glimpse of the human rights abuses suffered by women in U.S. prisons.  The book is essentially a set of edited interview transcripts with each chapter providing a first person account of a different currently or formerly incarcerated woman, and what these narrators reveal about their lives will cause all readers to shudder at the myriad physical, sexual, and psychological these women have endured.

The book’s editors, Robin Levi (Human Rights director of Justice Now) and Ayelet Waldman (best-selling author and essayist), used their combined expertise in advocacy and prose styling to knit together intellectually compelling and emotive testimonies from the more than seventy interviews they conducted with women who have endured imprisonment.  The book makes for a captivating read, but far more than that, it illuminates several major forms of injustice which characterize these women’s lives.

The level of healthcare provided to U.S. prisoners is not merely inadequate; it often constitutes torture.  One woman in this book was given a hysterectomy without her knowledge or consent–an incident which hearkens back to our nation’s troubled history of sterilizing African American and Puerto Rican women.  Other humiliating and sometimes potentially life-threatening instances of medical neglect and harm inflicted by guards and medical professionals pepper the life stories of the women in this book.  Women prisoners have been forced to give birth while shackled to hospital beds and given unnecessary C-sections, only to have their children taken from them within days of their births.  One incident in the book describes a hugely pregnant woman who is forced to bend over while naked and display her anus and vagina to guards during a strip search; because of her enormous belly, she struggled for several minutes to stand up again after this humiliation, and rather than offering to help her regain her balance, the guards mocked her.  Despite her many attempts to seek medical help in prison, another woman’s diabetes went untreated for so long that she nearly died.  It is a horrible thing for the uninsured and under-insured outside prisons to struggle (and often fail) to receive adequate health care.  Compounding this with incarceration adds a new level of terror.  The incarcerated face their medical problems in a place where they are cut off from family and friends, who often do not receive word of their loved ones’ illnesses or injuries until the prisoners are well enough to contact them or have died.  Prisoners cannot seek a second opinion about their medical care and do not always have access to their medical records.  They cannot advocate for themselves, and concerned parties in the free world must have uncommon knowledge and resources to be able to even attempt to advocate for incarcerated patients.

The fact that around 57% of incarcerated women endured sexual and/or physical abuse prior to their incarceration has been long observed by scholars but seldom seems to be absorbed by the general public or those who work in the criminal justice system.  The personal accounts in this book provide a solid emotional and intellectual grounding for lay readers and criminal justice experts alike to understand the contexts of the crimes women commit and the social forces which propel the poor life choices that land them in prison.

The likelihood that incarcerated people will be raped seems to be taken as an accepted fact by the general public in the U.S., as evidenced by the abundance of prison rape jokes which appear to crop up in even the most innocuous of places.  Why the notion of any person being raped would be funny to anyone is entirely beyond my comprehension, but I can only supposed that this dire reality for many prisoners seems humorous to people only when the folks making and responding to these jokes fail to see prisoners as human beings.  Inside This Place, Not of It brings home the vulnerability of people held captive by those who have the power to abuse them, often over the course of many years.

This book is the latest edition in McSweeney’s Press’s nonprofit Voice of Witness series, which uses oral histories to address social injustice and human rights crises.  This kind of publishing work is vital to record the lives of people who seldom have public platforms from which to tell their stories, and I commend Dave Eggers and the McSweeney’s staff for the brave and progressive work they do.

Inside This Place, Not of It will be released in October 2011.  Many thanks to whomever sent me an early galley of the manuscript!


2 Responses to “Book Review by Ashley Lucas: Inside This Place, Not of It, Eds. Robin Levi and Ayelet Waldman”


  1. The Awful Truth About Women’s Lives in Prison : Ms Magazine Blog - October 24, 2011

    […] with permission from Razor Wire Women. Print | Email | PDF#dd_ajax_float{ background:none repeat scroll 0 0 #FFFFFF; border:1px solid […]

  2. Ms. Magazine Blog Reprinted a Post from RWW! « Razor Wire Women - October 25, 2011

    […] Read it on this blog here. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: